Transformation

Why 70% of all transformations fail, and what successful companies do differently

Around 70% of all transformation initiatives fail. That figure has circulated in management literature for decades, and it has lost none of its edge. A 2023 study by McKinsey & Company confirms it: the majority of company-wide change initiatives do not reach their original goals, or do not reach them fully. At the same time the pressure on companies to transform faster and more deeply than ever keeps growing. How do those two things fit together? And what exactly do the successful 30% do differently?

Why transformations fail: the problem is rarely the technology

When transformations fail, people usually point at technology or budget first. Neither is often the real cause. In the overwhelming majority of cases the problem lies elsewhere: in a missing strategic vision, in a leadership team that does not really stand behind the change, or in employees who were involved too late, or not at all.

A transformation without a clear “why” is doomed. If the people in the company do not understand where the journey is going and why they should change, there is no basis at all for a willingness to change. Transformation needs a picture of the future that is convincing and concrete enough to generate energy, at every level of the organization.

Change management: too often too late

One of the most common mistakes we see in practice: change management is treated as an accompanying measure to be added once resistance becomes noticeable. That is like putting on the seatbelt after the crash. Professional change management belongs in the project plan from the first hour, not as an optional extra but as a requirement.

In practice that means stakeholder analyses during the design phase, communication plans that are not written only after the kick-off, and training concepts that keep pace with the technical implementation rather than trailing behind it.

In transformation and change management, leadership is not a footnote

Transformation only succeeds when leaders live it actively, not merely communicate it. Managers who are uncertain or skeptical about the change themselves inevitably pass that attitude on to their teams. The opposite is equally true: leaders who visibly support change, who allow questions and address uncertainty openly are the strongest accelerator a transformation has.

That often requires deliberate preparation. Workshops, coaching and regular sessions for reflection strengthen leaders' ability to make change understandable and to guide teams through phases of uncertainty without losing their own footing.

What successful transformations have in common

Companies that master transformation start with the “why”. They answer that question clearly, for the company as a whole and for every single employee. What changes in concrete terms? What stays? What is in it for me personally? That clarity creates motivation where there was resistance before.

They also measure systematically what they implement. Regular checkpoints, feedback loops and clear KPIs help adjust course where needed, because transformations rarely run in a straight line. The willingness to correct the approach without losing sight of the goal is what separates resilient transformations from rigid ones.

And finally they build on a methodologically solid foundation. Whether Prosci® ADKAR, Kotter's eight-step model or the Tiba Holistic Change-Management® approach, a structured frame gives the transformation stability without turning it into bureaucracy. Methods are not an end in themselves. They are tools for making complex human processes of change manageable.

Conclusion

The 70% statistic is not a force of nature. It is the result of known, avoidable mistakes, and with the right approach, the courage to be honest and a consistent focus on people it can reliably be reduced. Transformation succeeds when it is understood for what it really is: not an IT project, not a reorganization plan, but a deeply human process.

Would you like to put your transformation on a solid foundation?
Get in touch. Tiba Transformation Group has guided companies through complex processes of change for more than 37 years.

→ Free initial consultation: Get in touch

  

Literature

McKinsey & Company (2023). Losing from day one: Why even successful transformations fall short. McKinsey & Company, New York.

Kotter, J. P. (2012). Leading Change. Harvard Business Review Press, Boston.

Prosci® (2023). Best Practices in Change Management, 12th edition. Prosci, Fort Collins.

 

More blogs on the topic

The Tiba 4-Achsenkreuz®: why successful transformation needs four dimensions

Learn more

Why transformations fail: five patterns we see again and again, and what helps

Learn more

Boutique consultancy instead of consulting corporation: why small teams support large transformations better

Learn more